What Is Maisano Heart Surgery Scandal? USZ Pays Six-Figure Settlements
Image Source: USZ

Zurich University Hospital (USZ) has paid settlements in the “low six-figure” range to patients affected by the Maisano heart-surgery scandal.

The hospital says it received around 20 formal state-liability claims during the period under investigation, and that it has reached out-of-court settlements in all cases resolved so far. This disclosure is the first time USZ has provided a concrete figure for compensation paid to victims.

USZ says it received around 20 state-liability claims in the period examined. Of those, 14 were filed before the official investigation report was published, and the hospital says most of those cases are now closed.

The hospital told SRF that it reached out-of-court settlements in all cases resolved so far, with the total compensation paid described only as “low six figures.”

Read More: Switzerland Tops Global Innovation Ranking

What is the Maisano Heart Surgery Scandal?

The Maisano case concerns serious failings in USZ’s cardiac surgery department between 2016 and 2020, when an external investigation found that the department’s mortality rate was significantly higher than at comparable university hospitals. The investigation also found that the Cardioband, a medical implant used to treat heart-valve problems, was used inappropriately in several cases.

The scandal has been under scrutiny for years, with the external report triggering a wave of legal claims from affected patients and their families.

The hospital has now confirmed that those claims have translated into real financial settlements, though the exact total has not been made public.

More Claims Continue To Come

The Maisano scandal is significant because it involves not just medical error, but a systemic failure in oversight and quality control at one of Switzerland’s leading hospitals. The fact that patients had to file formal state-liability claims to obtain compensation shows how difficult it can be for victims to get redress through ordinary channels.

Since the investigation report was published, USZ says additional liability claims have arrived. The hospital has not yet quantified the damages in those cases and has therefore not set aside reserves to cover them.

That suggests the financial exposure is not yet fully known and the final settlement total could grow.

Akriti Seth
About the Author

Akriti Seth

Akriti Seth is a Zürich-based editor with more than a decade of experience, anchored by foundational training at Bloomberg. As a journalist, she covers global affairs, financial markets and technology. Her career has taken her from television studios to digital newsrooms. She has reported as an on-air correspondent for Channel NewsAsia and covered markets, corporate finance and business strategy for Informa UK. Her work has appeared in Entrepreneur Magazine, Hindustan Times, Yahoo Finance, TradingView, the Crypto Council for Innovation, DailyCoin, Tech Panda and more. She founded Helvetica Times to bring independent, English-language journalism to Switzerland — serving the expats, international professionals and global readers who want Swiss news reported with clarity and rigor.

View all articles