Nearly all challenges to initial rents in Switzerland come from just nine cantons where landlords are required to disclose the previous tenant’s rent on an official form, according to an analysis of federal conciliation statistics and cantonal form requirements.
The finding suggests that transparency about the previous rent may be a major driver of renters’ willingness to challenge potentially excessive initial rents.
Cantons without the disclosure requirement, including several with tight housing markets, produce dramatically fewer cases.
Cantons that require landlords to disclose the previous rent on an official form account for between 96.8% and 98.8% of settled initial-rent cases in every semester from 2023 H1 to 2026 H1, according to the analysis. Zurich alone accounted for 1,372 settled initial-rent cases over three and a half years.
By contrast, 14 cantons without the form but with vacancy rates at or below 1.5% produced just 68 cases over the same period. Those cantons include Schwyz, Basel-Landschaft, Obwalden and Uri, all of which face housing pressure but do not require the disclosure form.
For renters, the practical implication is clear: in cantons where the previous rent must be disclosed, tenants have a much stronger basis to challenge an initial rent they believe is excessive. In cantons without the form, tenants are largely left in the dark, even where housing is scarce.
READ MORE: What is Maisano Heart Surgery Scandal?
Swiss Renters Fight Back: Bern’s Form Made A Difference
Bern introduced the disclosure requirement on 1 December 2025, and the effect was immediate. The number of settled initial-rent cases in the canton more than doubled, rising from 10 in the previous period to 24 after the form took effect.
That suggests the form is not just a bureaucratic formality, but a practical tool that makes it easier for tenants to identify and challenge potentially excessive rents. The Swiss Tenants’ Association has long argued that transparency about the previous rent is essential for renters to exercise their rights.
Meanwhile, Vaud’s Backlog Continues To Grow
Vaud presents a different picture. Only about half of initial-rent cases in the canton end in agreement, compared with 90% in Zurich. Vaud’s backlog has also tripled to 1,533 cases.
That suggests the form alone does not solve the problem. In Vaud, the high volume of cases combined with a low agreement rate points to deeper structural issues, possibly including slower processing, more contested cases, or weaker incentives to settle.
What the Federal Data Shows
The Federal Office for Housing (BWO) reported that the number of new conciliation procedures in tenancy and lease law remained broadly stable in the first half of 2026, with 19,074 new cases, down 0.86% from the second half of 2025. The total number of cases handled, including carryovers, reached 31,177, with 18,969 resolved by the end of June.
The number of settled initial-rent cases rose by 12.92%, according to the BWO. The analysis puts the increase at 23.6%, from 670 to 828 cases, a discrepancy that needs to be clarified against the BWO’s methodology.
The findingsraise questions about policy. If the form is driving such a large share of challenges, expanding the requirement to more cantons could significantly increase renters’ ability to enforce their rights. A parliamentary counter-proposal, Curia Vista 26.4575, is expected to go into consultation in the first half of 2027, and could address some of these issues.